Advertising Issues: SEC and GIPS Performance in the Private Fund Space

Over a year ago, OCIE released the Risk Alert, “The Most Frequent Advertising Rule Compliance Issues Identified in OCIE Examinations of Investment Advisers.” While the alert highlighted several areas where performance advertising is involved, our recent CSS/Ascendant conference panelists in a session entitled “Best Practices for SEC and GIPS Performance in the Private Fund Space” noted that it is clear that hypothetical and back-tested returns continue to be a huge risk area. If it’s hypothetical, firms simply cannot be clear enough in their disclosures. Given that it’s hypothetical, it fundamentally didn’t happen, so there has to be a lot of disclosure about how it was created.

Robert Conca, Partner at Jacko Law Group mentioned that early on in the regulation of private funds and registrations, it became apparent that the rules don’t really apply like they do to other registrants. That thinking has certainly changed, and private funds are placing more importance on ensuring they’re buttoned up from a regulatory perspective. Additionally, clients are starting to ask more about GIPS compliance from private funds.

Appropriately representing returns to qualified investors stands as a major issue for Managing Partner Sidney Hardee of Hardee Brothers. His goal is to make sure the investors understand the full scope of the funds, which include the strategies, expenses, and returns. Additionally, he’s a strong proponent for having the Chief Compliance Officer, Chief Risk Officer, and Chief Investment Officer viewed as equal partners. Ensuring they all have an equal voice is important to make sure everyone is heard, and buys in to the final product.

Arin Stancil, Managing Director of Guardian Performance Solutions LLC noted that when typically thinking about private funds, GIPS compliance doesn’t always come to mind. As the GIPS standards are presently written, the applicability just simply isn’t there. For example, GIPS focuses on composites, which don’t jibe with the concept of selling private investments. The proposed “GIPS 2020” revised standards are an attempt to make GIPS more applicable to private funds. This improvement may lead to more private funds seeking compliance with the GIPS standards.

Other issues linger. Fees and expenses disclosures, for example, remain problematic. Disclosures around these should be much more thorough than was typically seen just a few years ago. These disclosures are expected by the examiners regardless of a firm’s size or investment philosophy. Be sure that multiple people read the disclosures to ensure everyone is on the same page, including the firm’s accounting/finance person/department. The worst thing an adviser can do is nothing, especially when an issue is identified. Firms have to demonstrate they care. It’s better to try and fail than to do nothing at all.

The regulatory focus on private fund issues will only continue. Rules and regulations apply. Continue to preach tone at the top, continue to fight for sufficient resources, continue to emphasize compliance as a strategic business partner. Firms must be able to demonstrate a strong culture of compliance, that policy and control breaches are not tolerated, that the firm is proactive in seeking to identify risks, and that supervisors are effective role models within the organization.


Subscribe to CSS Blog

CSS frequently publishes blog posts which are written by our team from their observations in the field, at conferences and through experiences with compliance professionals. These posts are designed to further knowledge and share industry best practices. Topics run the gamut, including Form ADV, cybersecurity, MiFID II, position limit monitoring, technology challenges and more. Complete and submit the brief form below to receive notifications when we publish new content.

Latest Content

Service Provider Due Diligence – Building Effective Partnerships

In 2009, the SEC stated at its CCOutreach Program that “when a service provider is utilized, the adviser still retains its fiduciary responsibilities for the delegated services.” This philosophy is as true today as it was 10-plus years ago. Therefore, the question becomes how do you establish a due diligence oversight program for your firm’s … Continued

SEC Adopts Changes to Reporting Forms

Regulation of Derivatives Use by RICs and BDCs Recognizing the proliferation of new derivate products in our markets, the SEC voted to adopt a new regulatory framework for the use of derivatives by mutual funds, ETFs, closed-end funds, and business development companies. The SEC’s press release stated that, “The new rule and rule amendments will … Continued

Time to Use the Bat Phone: Who to Call When a Compliance Officer Needs Help?

It seems that the burden of work continues to increase for compliance professionals in the investment management industry. While also ensuring that their compliance program is effective, compliance officers must also be aware of cybersecurity threats, business continuity plans, new regulations, changes in business strategy, and more – all while doing this under a work … Continued