Keep Your Eye on the Prize

For ERISA plan fiduciaries who thought they were being responsible and addressing participants’ demands by including investments in employee retirement plans that also support non-financial objectives, such as environment, social and corporate governance (“ESG”) goals, the Department of Labor (“DOL”) has weighed in. And they don’t necessarily agree.

In a proposal announced June 23, 2020, the DOL would seek to amend sections 404(a)(1)(A) and (B) of ERISA (the “Proposal”) to make clear that plan fiduciaries must focus first and foremost on maximizing potential investment returns and minimizing investment risks in the plan. All other non-pecuniary objectives must be subordinate.

The Proposal recognizes the increasing proliferation of ESG-focused investment vehicles and cites numerous concerns facing plan fiduciaries whose apparent good intentions might undermine the true objective of ERISA plans— maximizing retirement funds.  These issues include a lack of uniformity in defining an ESG investment, vague and/or inconsistent rating systems, inaccurate or incomplete disclosures, reduced returns, potentially greater risks, and higher fees. While recognizing the purported opportunity to further social causes that may be important to individual plan investors, the Proposal notes that “Providing a secure retirement for American workers is the paramount, and eminently-worthy, ‘social’ goal of ERISA plans”.[i]

The proposal seeks to codify the following points:

  • A plan fiduciary’s evaluation of an investment must be focused only on pecuniary factors that have a material effect on the return and risk of an investment.
  • Fiduciaries are prohibited from subordinating the financial interests of plan participants and beneficiaries to some other, non-pecuniary goal, either by sacrificing investment return or taking on additional investment risk.
  • Plan fiduciaries must consider alternative investments or investment courses of action.
  • When alternative investments are determined to be economically indistinguishable after thorough evaluation, and one of the investments is selected on the basis of a non-pecuniary factor or factors such as ESG considerations, the fiduciary must fully document the analysis undertaken.
  • Fiduciary standards also apply to a fiduciary’s selection of investments in 401(k) and other defined contribution individual plans which allow a plan participant to direct their investments into an array of options in the plan. The proposal explicitly sets forth the criteria that a fiduciary must consider in selecting investment options for such plans when the investment option includes ESG goals in their investment mandates, or in the fund name.

The full text of the rule proposal can be found here.

To speak with a CSS regulatory expert, email us at

[i] Department of Labor, Employee Benefits Security Administration, 29 CFR Part 2550, RIN 1210-AB95, Financial Factors in Selecting Plan Investments

Subscribe to CSS Blog

CSS frequently publishes blog posts which are written by our team from their observations in the field, at conferences and through experiences with compliance professionals. These posts are designed to further knowledge and share industry best practices. Topics run the gamut, including Form ADV, cybersecurity, MiFID II, position limit monitoring, technology challenges and more. Complete and submit the brief form below to receive notifications when we publish new content.

Latest Content

Service Provider Due Diligence – Building Effective Partnerships

In 2009, the SEC stated at its CCOutreach Program that “when a service provider is utilized, the adviser still retains its fiduciary responsibilities for the delegated services.” This philosophy is as true today as it was 10-plus years ago. Therefore, the question becomes how do you establish a due diligence oversight program for your firm’s … Continued

SEC Adopts Changes to Reporting Forms

Regulation of Derivatives Use by RICs and BDCs Recognizing the proliferation of new derivate products in our markets, the SEC voted to adopt a new regulatory framework for the use of derivatives by mutual funds, ETFs, closed-end funds, and business development companies. The SEC’s press release stated that, “The new rule and rule amendments will … Continued

Time to Use the Bat Phone: Who to Call When a Compliance Officer Needs Help?

It seems that the burden of work continues to increase for compliance professionals in the investment management industry. While also ensuring that their compliance program is effective, compliance officers must also be aware of cybersecurity threats, business continuity plans, new regulations, changes in business strategy, and more – all while doing this under a work … Continued